Why didn t arthur cough on micah " Dutch arrived just before John did because he came to kill Micah. Just like with Thomas Downes to Arthur, some of that blood may have touched Micah’s eye, or nose, even mouth. John and his family deserved better as well. All Micah wanted was a way to make money for him. Nothing that justifies all the secrecy. Would Arthur have beaten Micah if he wasn’t sick? Yes. He was a sweet man. “You worry too much, Dutch. If Arthur wanted to, Unlike Downes, Arthur had manners and didn’t cough in people’s faces. While attempting to stop the fight Because he doesn't know what's right or wrong anymore, and he doesn't trust that either Arthur or Micah is telling the truth. Even when he got the diagnosis which I assume is to be a very emotional scene I didn't even realize the scale of how things will change. In his condition, Arthur wouldn't be able to outshoot Micah. John can't even talk about Arthur in the epilogue. 4K votes, 264 comments. It doesn't matter whether they have high or low Honor, quit smoking, or drink every Health Tonic they can get their hands on; Arthur's death is basically inevitable. Why is Micah the most one dimensional cartoon bad guy that we have to suspend belief anyone in the gang doesn't just stab in the face. New comments cannot be posted. Not odd at all. Did Arthur give Abigail TB? It is heavily implied that Abigail caught tuberculosis from Arthur because she begins coughing a lot and it becomes more prominent during the first game. (Just didn’t do the mission) and later Strauss tells me “that downes guy is dead so his wife has to pay”. . poor arthur . ” “Arthur’s probably off doing something, Dutch. I never interacted with any sick guy or blood let’s see how this goes. Well, Why did Dutch choose Micah or Arthur? Dutch chose Micah over Arthur because he believed that Micah was the only loyal gang member left. Not immediately, because Arthur isn't stupid, but Ross is capable of being patient for the bigger prize. Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self-aware that he was sick but since it wasn’t serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). I can't tell if it's out of character for Micah to not kill Arthur with high honor. Why does Micah hate Arthur? The thing is that, if you look back when Arthur got to the shore of Guam's, you'd see that Micah seems to be pretty excited of his survival too, the truth is that Micah didn't hate Arthur, he never did, it was first cowardice, as he ratted out the whole gang fearing to be killed, which eventually changed him. Failing that, any airborne particles may have infected Micah. On my first playthrough i thought the cutscene ride back to camp was a little misplaced after this mission, but didn't think too much of it. Arthur would have been disappointed in John at that moment. Micah says early on in the game that he looks up to Arthur. Killing Micah might have gone In his mind those specific guns were worth more than the lives of a whole town. Dutch was just going to do it the smart way rather then shooting his way up a mountain: Dutch would kill Micah in a job by "accident. This plan probably involved Micah's prior associates. That's just the problem. Why didn t anyone catch TB from Arthur? So now the online Youtubers are trying to state that Arthur didn't get TB from Chapter 2 Downes mission. Imagine if Arthur during his chapter 2 strength went against Micah. Even if he does this mission before the mission where he gets sick, he would still cough. How do you stop Arthur from coughing? Thomas was the one in Valentine handing out pamphlets to help the needy and he stopped arthur from killing that guy at the saloon. Very shortly after stopping Arthur from shooting Micah, you can see that Dutch realizes Arthur is right and Micah is wrong. Arthur: (Coughs) [Micah grabs his gun and aims it at Arthur] Micah: You're not better than me, Morgan. r/RDR2. Also gang code. I'm guessing it was because he could see the signs of TB. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online. You know what really pisses me off about the fight at the end with Micah it’s not that Micah betrayed the gang or started attacking Arthur because I saw that coming, it’s the fact that in the end the only thing holding Arthur back is the fucking TB because if this fight took place in chapter 2 Arthur would fucking slaughter Micah it wouldn’t even be a contest Arthur wouldn’t even need I knew he wasn't going to make it. 8. With his physical strength, Arthur would have In an early mission, Arthur has to collect a loan-shark debt from Thomas Downes, who was a poor farmer with a bad cough. I think Micah wanted Dutch to go with him to hand him over. If you have high honor, there will be a deer. Pearson met some O'Driscolls on the road who said they wanted to arrange a parley. I don't think he wanted them to know. According to the article, Micah is safe from contracting TB from Arthur. I also feel Arthur, despite his previous respect and love for Dutch, didn't call him out enough in the end. Arthur only killed when he had to and as self defense on those robberies. They believe Micah was the true villain. I think that he felt it was HIS fault, ultimately. in the mission red dead redemption in chapter 6, when arthur rides back to beaver hollow to tell dutch micah is the rat, and confronts him. Grimshaw was in relationship with Dutch. none of these gang members are putting up with this guy, Dutch or no Dutch Why didn’t any of Arthur’s friends catch tuberculosis during Red Dead Redemption 2? Tuberculosis is contracted by direct contact with infected bodily fluids. Arthur was the physically strongest man in the Van der Linde gang alongside Charles. The fact he was coughing, while engaging with his friends and not warning them about his disease seemed odd. Why did Dutch betray Arthur? There are a few reasons why Arthur didn’t kill Micah. Ross didn't believe Arthur and figured if he let him go and waited enough, Arthur would lead him to Dutch and the rest of the gang. Also you can just discard the cigarettes you don't have to smoke them. In my first ever play through and heard Micah say black lung to Arthur I was confused because Arthur never told the gang he had TB. In a bad Honor playthrough, however, Arthur is shot by former van der Linde gang member Micah Bell. Just finished the game a few days ago, a roller payer of emotions, but Dutch and others die, I’m still pissed off at strauss and thankfully, I somehow turned around when Arthur started to be less of a dick and got the good ending, sad game, I have so much to say but everyone thinks the same, in Red Dead everything else is fixed, so I’m happy. My second time around, this scene really hit me. Without tuberculosis, he wouldn’t be coughing blood, losing weight, Would Arthur beat Micah if he wasn t sick? Yes. And I know I’ll get downvoted for this but Arthur didn’t need to beat Thomas that hard. (Note: dead things are an omen that seems to follow Micah around. Bam, you've got TB. Sadie deserved better. The pinkertons didn't know where they were camped they just knew the general area and by the way bar fights happened almost every day back then,shady belle was very secluded and Arthur didnt betray Dutch he was just challenging and giving suggestions Reply reply duffmcduffster • • That’s why he didn’t put a bullet in Micah’s head the moment he discovered he was a 🐀. Now, years later, Dutch Van Der Linde arrives at Micah’s wanting to kill him. All that talk about freedom and family and loyalty, was for nothing. He still wanted to live in the outlaw days and couldn't accept that the new age had no place for cowboys. Best. They didn't leave him, they just didn't have a track to follow. But he also knew he was already going to die from TB (high honor ending) so why not shoot Micah, knowing your already going to die even if you don’t? Hope I did good explaining On the way to Saint Denis, Arthur collapses and is dragged to the local doctor who diagnoses him with his illness. That's a big part of Why does Arthur see a coyote? These animals represent Arthur’s honor, if he has low honor, there will be a coyote. I tried to stop you. There are actually two ways Arthur can die, depending on a variety of player choices. Micah juuls creme brulee Absolutely Leon, I think Arthur would be sitting on his front porch with a loaded shotgun at hand when Ross turns up. Once you do, he'll give you three targets, and even if you try to get smart and only do the other two, eventually he'll remind you of Downes, and the mission begins automatically. Arthur will still look sick so i HIGHLY recommend F4rkun4U's Looking Healthy I doubt it has to do with Dutch ego. Regardless of his feelings towards those people. Last sense before Micah took her life. Also he mysteriously knew who he got the disease I guess Arthur thinks that he’s better than that. "I This could even work if Arthur didn't get TB, as again, he is assuming he'll die on that mountain - just without the illness, the assumption would be that the Pinkertons or Micah/Dutch would kill him instead. There’s a myriad of reasons why Micah wouldn’t/couldn’t have contracted TB from Arthur, even if Arthur had coughed blood and phlegm directly in to Micah’s lungs. In the mission “A Fork in the Trail,” Arthur Morgan goes to visit Sadie Adler but is No, to end chapter 2 it is necessary to catch TB from Thomas Downes. WE have covid. It’s amazing how many people still don’t understand the central theme of Red Dead, which is that revenge isn’t the answer. Why is arthur coughing? Is it because I smoked too much or did he get sick in Guarma? can i cure it or is it like a idle animation? SPOILER: I found out why he is coughing. If you really don’t want Arthur to get sick, just don’t progress past that point. This led to the "Gang as Family" coming to an end. Even though shit went downhill due to Dutchs decisions and the lies Micah was feeding Dutch Arthur at the end of the day was a son of van der linde. It's not like Tuberculosis is some magic zone of death. They obviously If Arthur jus killed Micah that could turn Dutch completely if it happens before he realizes Micah is scum. It couldn't have been out of fear of dying because Arthur knew he would die anyway. Challenging the Narrative: The theory that Hosea might have infected Arthur with tuberculosis questions the traditional belief that Thomas Downs was responsible, offering a fresh perspective on the storyline. Can you beat Micah as Arthur? There’s no way a healthy Arthur would lose to Micah. Why couldn’t Arthur just shoot Micah? Arthur knew that if he shot Micah, the rest of the gang except john would kill him. Grimshaw joined the gang as long as Arthur. Dutch was introduced as a fearless Robin Hood leader of a gang. Can Arthur avoid TB? Arthur: I didn't turn, Micah. Why didn t Arthur infect anyone else? Why didn’t any of Arthur’s friends catch tuberculosis during Red Dead Redemption 2? Why does Micah leave Arthur to die in High honor and and personaly kill him in Low honor. Arthur would've gone on, but another cough bent him double and stole his breath. Tell Dutch what you said to agent Milton. the Nickname cowpoke he constantly gives arthur is after arthur calls him the same thing throughout chapters 1-4. Even in the later stages, where he's coughing up blood, you have to be fairly close to him to catch it from his It would honestly be super interesting to have the ending with John and Micah change depending on your honor level: If you played honorably, John gets to honorably fight a strong Micah, but if you’ve played dishonorably and Arthur spits in Micah’s face, you have to fight a revealed-to-be very sick Micah, who honestly can’t fight well anymore. " By 1907, Dutch is a shell of his former sense, a shadow of the man he once was. Keep in mind as well that Javier was even able to drop Micah in one punch, and even he couldn't beat I didn’t interact with Thomas downed at all. Would Arthur beat Micah if he wasn’t sick? It is uncertain if Arthur would have been able to defeat Micah if he wasn’t sick. I also don’t see why Milton would lie to Arthur when he had him at gunpoint about Micah being a rat before Guarma. Reply Why didn't Arthur spit in the face if Micah when they were fighting? Reply I mean: Micah gets TB By the time John finds him, Why does Arthur cough so much rdr2? On the way to Saint Denis, Arthur collapses and is dragged to the local doctor who diagnoses him with his illness. He would have had to spit on them or sneezed on them in order for them to catch it. That mission literally showed us Arthur in his prime against what he comes in chapter 6. Either way, I question why even with high honor, he doesn't kill Arthur I find it weird that with high honor, Micah doesn't bother taking the opportunity to finally kill Arthur, yet instead he just runs away after a fight. He made it back to camp so, whatevs to everyone else. Is Arthur mentioned in RDR1? Why doesn’t Arthur cough on Micah and give him TB? Locked post. Lenny and Tilly and everyone else deserved better. Arthur is stronger than Micah. The tuberculosis weakened Arthur’s physical abilities and made him more vulnerable in combat. Why wasn't his wife sick with TB. it seemed at first he was hiding it but then all of a sudden, everyone knew? I get they could've noticed and assumed but I just expected that I can only imagine they gave Micah the same deal and that's why Micah was so keen for Dutch to go with him at the end and didn't care about Bill and Javier leaving. The real-life answer for why Micah doesn't get sick actually hits close to how the current COVID-19 pandemic and the way that it is transferred from host to host. We all saw how physical weak tuberculosis made Arthur. According to CDC recommendations 12 votes, 29 comments. That's the reason he walks away. 305K subscribers in the RDR2 community. He implied he was not well to a couple of folks but didn't go into much detail. The reason he doesn't try to stop Arthur getting the gun is cause he can just shoot him as he grabs it. then javier goes to the camp to say the pinkertons are coming, and micah shoots miss grimshaw, dutch ignores this what’s weird. When you interact with her and her son you get the “how about keep her in black on your behalf” line from Arthur. Micah: You shut your mouth. I feel like most people say, "Oh he had a change of heart near the end of his life so he's a good person", completely discounting the hundreds of innocents he killed voluntarily I'm not sure why this has made me cry so much, but I have felt genuinely depressed all day. By the time he sat back up, Dutch had lost his kindly demeanor, replaced by the familiar look of impatience and frustration. Hosea calls it a trap, but Micah seems to think it is worth looking into, and helps convince Dutch to go. Im staying in chpt 2-3 forever. That built up speculation is what led to Dutch testing Arthur and giving up on the gang’s morale instead of just testing Micah. Share Sort by: Best. One of Arthur's main character traits is loyalty to the gang and those in it. Arthur accompanies Dutch and Micah as a Didn’t Micah kill pinkertsons in Annesberg when Dutch shot Cornwall? Micah is just as dirty as Dutch and the whole gang, he is probably 2nd most wanted aside from Arthur. Did Arthur give anyone else TB? There is no mention of anyone else in the game Same here. This is when Arthur is exposed/infected with Tuberculosis. 5), and I believe you have to do those first few collections for Strauss at some point in chapter 2 (at least, Thomas Downes for sure) since that's part of the story. How come Arthur didn’t spread TB? Why didn’t any of Arthur’s friends catch tuberculosis during Red Dead Redemption 2? Tuberculosis is contracted by direct contact with infected bodily fluids. They are trying to pass it on that he got it while on the boat from a sailor in Chapter 5. Arthur didn't have the diagnosis yet so I don't know if this was a glitch that made Micah say that earlier of if he was just making fun of the cough. I had a feeling where that was going. Arthur got it because Thomas Downes had coughed into his mouth, so his infected Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self aware he was sick but since it wasn’t serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). He really In the final mission before the epilogue, I understand if your honor is high, whether you help John or go back for the money Arthur dies from his disease. Where the Pinkertons went is also a good question. Dutch was like a teacher to him. Mission Overview []. Why is Hosea coughing RDR2? Throughout the game, players can hear Dutch and other members of In a particular mission, Arthur coughs as a sign of his illness. You did. Suspecting a trap, Micah asks Arthur to observe an arranged meeting between Dutch and Colm O'Driscoll from afar. Funny thing is that if Micah dies the Edgar Ross can't track down John and his family. Micah only got the best of him because Arthur was practically gasping for air by the end. Add a Comment. When Arthur starts to have his redemption arc Micah begins to see him as weak and pathetic, and in the end decides he isn’t worth finishing off. Prior to Leopold Strauss' debt-collection mission, Downes can be seen on a street corner taking donations for charity and breaking up a bar fight before it turned fatal. He even said that. Without tuberculosis, he wouldn't be coughing blood In a particular mission, Arthur coughs as a sign of his illness. Make fun of me if you want, I just wanted to type this out and hope someone can When Micah is laying on top of Arthur and landing punches to his face, he answers "i'm a survivor black lung, a survivor" and so on after Arthur says he knows. Arthur is already coughing! (Which is why Arthur only starts coughing after Blessed are the Peacemakers, But it doesn't happen anywhere else when he's doing strenuous stuff or anything else until some time after Blessed are the Peacemakers. Old. Could Arthur have beaten Micah if he wasn’t sick? Yes, Arthur would have been able to defeat Micah if he wasn’t sick. I think Milton was using misdirection when he said molly never said a word (she obviously did, she blatantly admitted to it) and wanted to divide the gang further by Can you avoid Arthur getting TB? No, getting sick is integrated into the story. To which I say. Unlike Downes, Arthur had manners and didn’t cough in people’s faces. This mod removes these things. I don't think Arthur was very telling about his condition. Thinking that Arthur is on Micah's level of evil is straight delusional, however, thinking that Arthur was a good person is also straight delusional as he has commited evil acts too, some of which are on Micah's level. After Arthur and Micah beat each other into a stalemate he is in no condition to go anywhere anyway, because back then TB was a death sentence and as it progressed would take a severe physical toll. It was only a matter of time, and Arthur didn't have the luxury of taking it easy to delay the inevitable. It just does not add up to me. You can do everything else before Micah probably acting the way he did when he was scouting with Lenny (then ending up in jail in Strawberry). Micah has been trying to turn Dutch against Arthur and John for most of the game and it had finally worked due to a variety of factors ranging from Dutch's own mental issues to Hosea's death to how suspicious everything about John and Abigail in Saint-Denis was to Arthur losing all faith in Dutch. Couldn't stand to see such a powerhouse character so crippled and wheezing, not even capable of a quarter of the I mean: Micah gets TB By the time John finds him, However, he never antagonizes anyone who he views as a potential threat to him, hence why he tends to leave Dutch and Hosea alone. Then, as Team Arthur and Team Micah slowly widened that rift, Dutch struggled in vain to close it. Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. He can't trust himself, his decisions led the gang to where they were in the end. So other than Charles and maybe Sadie, i dont recall Arthur telling fellow gang member about his TB, however everyone seems to know that he will die: Strauss implies in a conversation that he is almost dead, Micah obviously calling him Black Lung, In a Mission Dutch says that Arthur needed to rest. I don't understand how you could get those mixed up. If players stop participating in story missions before Arthur dies, he’ll technically keep on yee-hawing for as long as the player desires. Downes didn't cough on Arthur the other two times though. I blame Strauss for lending money to a dying man. Abigail was also accused of being that rat by Micah since she didn’t get caught during the saint denis bank heist and since John didn’t get killed during that same heist meaning that her opinion wouldn’t really help fix the gang. Anyways, when I first played A Fork in the Road that sprung to my mind as the doc examined Arthur. Nobody is injured since Micah's army is tiny. " But I couldn't. It's actually a miracle and unrealistic no one else in the camp got sick with it. That's true, but based on some context clues I think it's also around the time Micah starts snitching Who were Micah's prior associates / Why did Micah join van der Linde. Neither Micah or Arthur were in the wrong in his view at that moment, he was. He didn't care about the gang or any of the principles the gang Why did Dutch walk away from Arthur and Micah? Because Micah was a dishonest rat who manipulated Dutch. Strauss went below that line by preying on those who didn’t have This is my first post in this sub and sorry if it doesn't belong here. The only way he helps Ross in the position of John would be if Ross was able to exploit him by capturing someone he cared about, the most likely candidate being Mary, though it’s possible Ross kidnapping Charlotte or Sadie might work but Arthur In the high honor help John escape ending, Dutch, Micah and Arthur all come together on the mountain. He as well as Arthur believed that Micah turned Dutch against the gang when he was in a bad spot. Probably because of their previous relationship. Couldn't stand to see such a powerhouse character so crippled and wheezing, not even capable of a quarter of the In my playthrough, I didn't really notice significant coughing until Guarma (Ch. Tl,dr: all diseases require a vector (Arthur in this case), but many diseases can 'lie low' with no symptoms (latency, dormancy, subclinical infections) until the immune system is Arthur always resented Micah because he considered him cruel, but he didn't really want him dead until he found out he was the Pinkertons' mole, at which point he might as well just have Micah gets TB. As the game goes on, Arthur becomes more and more sick, people in the gang die or Micah knows exactly where to go, as well: they stop off and Micah sends Arthur up to a ridge to keep watch on the exchange. The gunslinger was picked up as a teen by the outlaw Dutch van der Linde and his associate Hosea Matthews and would eventually grow up to be a ruthless, violent bandit who cares little for the When you get tuberculosis you gradually get worse core debuffs, coughing, if you overeat food doesn't refill cores for a while, ambient (non-story random npcs) calling you sick, and different straining noises from melee and jumping. Micah only gets put in the antagonist spot after arthur is no longer strong enough to keep him under hs boot and at that point micah begins to be openly antagonistic to arthur. In a particular mission, Arthur coughs as a sign of his illness. The tuberculosis only gets worse from there; with Arthur suffering from bouts of coughing to losing 20% of his stamina, health, and dead eye cores for the remainder of the player’s time with him. Arthur stood on the side of the Family, and Dutch stood on the other side (his own side, thinking "He" was the gang). The short exchange between Arthur and Thomas seems minuscule in the Why is arthur coughing? Corona virus I'm sure he aquired from Micah fackin Bell! (no Arthur doesn’t die) Reply reply More posts you may like r/RDR2. Why doesn’t Micah kill High Honor Arthur? Micah shoots Arthur, while going back for the money, he stabs him). On one mission with Charles to save the Indians son Charles mentions to Arthur that he hopes he can find peace inside before he dies I think the reason Arthur helped John and changed was a way if finding inner peace before his inevitable demise Arthur also knew that he couldn’t save himself and that John had a future in his family, and Arthur Specifically spits around Arthur's mouth area hoping he will pass on the sickness. So That's why he didn't react to Arthur crying that Micah was the rat as he succumbed to illness (high honor ending) Dutch already knew. I don't think Dutch knew to trust Micah, he Why did Dutch betray Arthur? SPOILERS: Micah was the problem, and Dutch was a problem because he started listening more to Micah than to Hosea and Arthur. Top. I think Dutch wasn't sure when Arthur died which is why he didn't leave with Micah and the money. Probably the same reason why when Arthur tells Milton he has TB, Sadie and Abigail didn't say anything and they didn't act or/and look surprised. Why can’t Arthur kill Micah? Arthur didn’t kill Micah because he wanted John to have a chance to pay him back and start a new life in the epilogue, which would be more satisfying. First time I noticed him calling him black lung was during an argument or some other form of jabs at eachother and arthur started coughing pretty badly and Micah just laughed and started calling him black lung, just figured it was a jab at his apparently now That’s not really how TB works. But why doesn't he give Arthur the gun back nor shoot Micah hinself? The first and most obvious thing players will say about Red Dead Redemption 2's story is that, had Arthur not fallen ill, he wouldn't have died. why didn’t arthur just kill micah when micah shot miss grimshaw? like at that point he hey guys, so I couldn't get a spoiler tag in the title but I just finished the game the other day and first of all best game I've played by far, but secondly I was curious if Arthur ever told anyone he had TB besides in random stranger missions. To postpone it as long as possible, don't take Strauss' first mission. He shared drinks, food and Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah? Arthur was self aware he was sick but since it wasn’t serious he probably tried to avoid coughing on any of his friends (or allies). I didn't expect the character to be so great, and I really didn't take how slow and painful it came. At that point in the story, Micah was just an annoying mouthy asshole. Key Takeaways. Likewise, until Arthur is diagnosed with tuberculosis in RDR2, Micah doesn't go too far in antagonizing him. TB is a very contagious disease. Idk maybe there’s stuff that I left out as to why Arthur didn’t just kill Micah, but It should be fairly obvious as why he didn’t kill Dutch. In a good Honor playthrough of RDR2, he dies of tuberculosis, a rapidly worsening illness that plagues him throughout the game. Just giving the vision that Dutch too could have been redeemed with the decision to follow John Arthur and the gang and not Micah Didn’t matter imho Micah was whispering in his ear and clearly was trying to insight trouble I wanted Red Dead Redemption 2 follows the slow deterioration of the Van der Linde gang, mirrored by Arthur Morgan's worsening tuberculosis. A lot of these theories suggesting that Arthur didn't get TB from Downes are difficult to accept because they fundamentally negate the point of Arthur's arc and his 'redemption'. If Arthur continues to have low honour then he sees Arthur as more of a threat and decides not to risk leaving him alive. Q&A. It's just John VS Dutch and ofc Dutch is convinced enough and It is uncertain if Arthur would have been able to defeat Micah if he wasn’t sick. Depending on how you play, you can still relatively beat Micah pretty soundly Arthur didn't want them to be in danger. Many have tried to skip the mission: you can’t. I find it weird that with high honor, Micah doesn't bother taking the opportunity to finally kill Arthur, yet instead he just runs away after a fight. Dutch probably made a plan on how to get Arthur out of Colm's hands, when Dutch gets a clue on Arthur's location. So they don't. He talks about how before they would Rob rich folk but they had a bottom line on who they stole from. If he did he’d be as bad as the rat himself and he doesn’t want anyone else to suffer like he did even if it is his worse enemy. The tuberculosis only gets worse from there; with Arthur suffering from bouts of coughing to losing 20% of his stamina, health, and dead eye cores for the remainder of the player's time with him. Why didn’t Arthur infect others with TB in RDR2? Unlike Thomas Downes, Arthur does not cough in people’s faces and keeps his distance when he begins coughing. Story []. He steps on Arthur’s hand and leaves him to die, showing his changed loyalty towards Micah. She picked Arthur side and then she got shot. Controversial. The raid on the ferry in Blackwater was Micah's plan. Can you avoid Arthur getting sick? After the heist you are REQUIRED to go to the Downes Ranch. ; Evidence from Gameplay: Hosea's persistent cough and illness, as highlighted in camp conversations, suggest a possible link to Did Micah get tuberculosis from Arthur? No, Micah Bell did not contract tuberculosis from Arthur’s blood. What does the Honor matter for Micah. Took the eye part out of the Money ending. After Arthur revealed that Micah was the true traitor, Dutch was in denial, unwilling to believe his protégé's allegations that Micah could possibly be disloyal. Arthur Morgan, the protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2, is one of the most complex and layered characters in Rockstar’s history and probably gaming history, too. It’s why Dutch tells John Marston he’s there for the same reason John is. I remember figuring something serious was wrong when Micah called me "Black Lung" at the camp though. The plan could have been Micah joins van der Linde and During the mission, "Money Lending and Other Sins (part 3) in Chapter 2. Why did Arthur just let him do that? I don't think "Because Dutch would have been mad if he did. I was like oh no why doesn’t he stop coughing. What they could've done was had Micah come out coughing and looking a bit sick during John and his standoff on the mountain because Arthur did inadvertently pass on his TB and he'd be like Micah is constantly snorting, and has a hacking cough, Arthur Morgan and Micah Bell couldn't be further apart in terms of their character quirks and outlook on life. Also that Dutch killed Micah and as he walked away he didn’t see much point to shoot him. More than half the gang, with the new idiots, were Micah's. They say nobody states downes had TB, or when he dies. And if Arthur didn't break free by himself, Colm's plan to get Dutch behind bars Who implied it's skippable? He's just saying he has yet to do the mission but Arthur is coughing. Sean, Kieran, Lenny, Hosea, Arthur. he coughs before Strauss and the player assumes its due to the smoking/other stuff, then after Strauss it takes the persistent coughing fits and the coughs that leave him clinging to something for the player to realise something ain't right. One reason is that Arthur was weakened by tuberculosis, which affected his overall health and physical abilities. I can see why Rockstar didn't show it at first since they wanted to keep the whole doubting Dutch thing a mystery as to whether he's losing his touch . Infact Arthur coughed and touched alot people before even chapter 6. That's why Arthur gets it from that dude, he's beating his ass, and then the guy coughs and it sprays blood into Arthur's eyes. I think having him cough that early was more of an oversight than anything really. Micah seems to have always been jealous of Arthur and his close bond with Dutch, stating that he had been "waiting a long time to do this" in the potential knife fight with Arthur. Arthur will still look sick so i HIGHLY recommend F4rkun4U's Looking Healthy Dutch tells John why he is there: "Same as you, I suppose. Downes coughed on Arthur and just went on with my day. He really didn’t know what he had until a doctor told him he had tuberculosis. Why didn’t Arthur shoot Micah at the end of the game . Why doesn’t Micah like Arthur? The thing is that, if you look back when Arthur got to the shore of Guam’s, you’d see that Micah seems to be pretty excited of his survival too, the truth is that Micah didn’t hate Arthur, he never did, it was first cowardice, as he ratted out the whole gang fearing to be killed, which eventually changed him. You're talking nonsense. But the point is, there's no great maguffin there. Arthur was a good person and didn't deserve this shit. He also kept some distance from them whenever he began coughing. I. It got me confused since then why Dutch didn't even bother to kill Micah by then. After the diagnosis, Micah views Arthur as weak and therefore a target. ” Because Micah doesn’t give a fuck about anyone but Micah. "Between us, I didn't do anything wrong. but that’s not my question. Why is Arthur coughing RDR2? On the way to Saint Denis, Arthur collapses and is dragged to the local doctor who diagnoses him with his illness. The character "Thomas Downes" coughs blood into Arthur's face. true. Spoiler It established earlier in the mission that Arthur can still draw faster than Micah despite his tuberculosis he still had his guns too so he really coulda just pulled his gun shot Micah left and died somewhere else so why didn’t he When Micah punches Arthur on the cliff or stabs him in Beaver Hollow, before being in close contact with him, some of Arthur’s blood goes flying. From day fucking one no one mattered to Dutch Vanderlin except Dutch Vanderlin. A/N: From all the blood spilled in that fistfight, it's a miracle Micah didn't get tuberculosis. Reply reply Ok you can’t have Arthur kill Dutch and Micah’s but does Arthur have to be crawling on his knees and either be killed or spared? When Dutch shoots Micah in the epilogue, is it because he is deeply regretful of Arthur's death and kills Micah in revenge regardless of whether he's a rat or not, or is it because he now truly believes Micah to be a rat and kills him to correct the mistake years ago? Why is Arthur coughing so much? On the way to Saint Denis, Arthur collapses and is dragged to the local doctor who diagnoses him with his illness. Why does Arthur cough so much RDR2? Arthur Wouldn’t Have Died. Why did no one get TB from Arthur? Why didn’t any of Arthur’s friends catch tuberculosis during Red Dead Redemption 2? Tuberculosis is contracted by direct contact with infected bodily fluids. Nothing but fucking pawns When you get tuberculosis you gradually get worse core debuffs, coughing, if you overeat food doesn't refill cores for a while, ambient (non-story random npcs) calling you sick, and different straining noises from melee and jumping. Why didn t Dutch save John? ‘ He had grown more paranoid and manic after Hosea’s death and the botched Saint Denis robbery, with Arthur even beginning to turn on him. That doesn't mean Arthur couldn't have already contracted it from Downes in the brawl in Valentine. New. E. An act of vengeance, if not atonement - which is why, in the standoff, he shoots Micah, but more importantly, why he leaves John the money. A large portion of why Dutch was losing it was also because the conflict that the new age was presenting to him. Can you cure Arthur Morgan? Unfortunately, no matter what players do, Arthur can't be cured in RDR2. Even if he does this mission before the mission where he gets sick, built up speculation is what led to Dutch testing Arthur and giving up on the gang’s morale instead of just testing Micah. why doesn't Arthur just put a hole in his head at any time during the game. It's hard for them to talk about something sensitive and emotional. Either way, I question why even with high honor, he doesn't kill Arthur I honestly didn't think anything about the time when Mr. Arthur viewed themselves as Robin Hood types. People cheering when John kills Micah clearly don’t understand that John seeking vengeance is what led to his demise. He also kept some distance from them whenever he began coughing. But I don't think they would randomly show Arthur coughing if it wasn't connected to TB. It must be that I don't really tend to analyze scenes that deeply. Had to get my Arthur to vape because he was coughing so much Reply [deleted] • Additional comment actions [removed] Reply KingOfTheCheesesteak • Additional comment actions. If Dutch knew he was in the right. Arthur didn't just run into Downes randomly, he Specifically spits around Arthur's mouth area hoping he will pass on the sickness. " is a good answer. I knew he wasn't going to make it. TB is caused by a bacteria (mycobacterium tuberculosis) that is spread by close contact with an infected individual, either through airborne transmission (ie you breath in bacteria floating in the air after someone with TB is coughing) or through contact with droplets (spit, blood, etc) with direct or indirect contact with your respiratory tract. I also don't think it was to protect John, because nobody was aiming at him and he was also armed (I also find it weird John didn't draw his guns It wasn't all Micah though. Open comment sort options. It wouldn't have been a contest. Arthur: Whatever you Gotta get that 2nd holster from Micah. Share Sort by: I didn’t personally find it to be inconsequential. What pisses me off is that Arthur, if he was healthy, would have turned Micah inside out. By the time John finds him, Micah is sick af. Despite being basically polar opposites, Red Dead Redemption 2's protagonist Arthur Morgan and antagonist Micah Bell share something in common. Without tuberculosis, he wouldn’t be coughing blood, losing weight, and generally feeling horrible all the time. Why did Arthur not cough on Micah? Arthur didn’t cough on Micah because he had manners and avoided coughing in people I also believe he coughs early on to distract the player from when he gets the TB. Arthur Vs Micah – Who’s Stronger. He chose to give his life for John's (and go through other redemptive acts) because of the illness, but it doesn't have to be written Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Do you remember him telling anyone "I have TB"? I don't. Dutch stepping on the gun stopped Micah shooting Arthur. But once Arthur has TB, it's not really guarenteed that he gives it to anyone else. It’s only a sentence or maybe two, but it struck me as significant. "I didn't need to be stopped," he said in a forced calm. I didn't catch it yet but they state a sailor coughs on Arthur. When Arthur and Micah fall, Micah still has both his guns. And while Arthur didn't particularly like him, I don't think that he saw him as the problem that he would eventually be. He believes that by killing Micah, he is avenging the downfall of the gang and the death of his surrogate son, Arthur Morgan. I think he was on that mountain with Micah to murder Micah - to deny him the money for which the gang had been doomed. Arthur just taking to the gang doesn’t give too high of a chance of contracting it, and Arthur isn’t always in everyone’s faces which would increase the risk. Yet with low honor he does kill him. Additionally, Arthur’s character arc throughout the game involved him growing as a person and realizing the importance of doing what is right. I thought that this was a side mission, and that if you didn’t do this !>Arthur was killed by Micah?!< Thomas was the one in Valentine handing out pamphlets to help the needy and he stopped arthur from killing that guy at the saloon. I don't recall him ever telling anyone he had TB. I think Bill, Javier, and John all notice it, but they're similar types of men to Arthur. Could Arthur have survived tuberculosis? Arthur didn’t need a diagnosis to tell him that he was going to die; even if he somehow escaped being shot or hanged, his death is an inevitability. Why did Dutch betray Arthur? In the battle against the US Army with the Indians, Dutch seemingly left Arthur to die, believing that a “disloyal“ Arthur was no longer any use for him. Arthur was the physically strongest Did Micah get tuberculosis from Arthur? Micah insults him and mocks his conditions, Bill tells Micah to shut up, but doesn't mention it otherwise. But if your honor is low, whichever A healthy Arthur could beat Micah with both hands tied behind his back . Because Micah kissed Dutch’s 🫏 constantly. I don’t think he spit on purpose. How did Arthur not infect others? Because Arthur isn’t Thomas Downes. yeah, I always saw it as Arthur coughing due to the dust in the air caused by moving the chest off the ground. He even confirmed that Molly wasn’t a rat herself in that same interaction I think it was just the result of the gangs violent crimes catching up to them, and Dutch doing whatever he can to fix a doomed situation Why does Micah call Arthur Black Lung? Micah often flaunts his new position as Dutch's right-hand man at Arthur and ridicules his tuberculosis, calling him “Black Lung”. nrrmd bobwra qytr pxohsi xtgxod qfpvj lyjiy xyhpi psocc zjec